Ans. China’s approval of the world’s largest hydroelectric project on the Yarlung Tsangpo (or Zangbo) River in Tibet has raised significant concerns among downstream countries, particularly India. Once completed, the Medog Hydropower Station, with a generating capacity of 60,000 MW, will be three times more powerful than the world’s largest hydroelectric project, the Three Gorges Dam on the Yangtze River. The Yarlung Tsangpo, known as the Siang River in Arunachal Pradesh and the Brahmaputra in Assam, holds immense significance for millions of people who rely on its waters for agriculture, drinking, and livelihoods. Given the scale of the project and its location in Tibet, its geopolitical and environmental ramifications for India and the wider region are profound.

Impact on the Flow of Water and Environmental Concerns

The Yarlung Tsangpo River plays a crucial role in the hydrological cycle of several countries in South Asia, flowing from Tibet into India and Bangladesh. China’s planned hydropower project on the river, located at the "Great Bend" in Medog county, could have far-reaching consequences for the river’s flow. As a downstream state, India is particularly vulnerable to any changes in water flow, sediment transport, and overall river morphology.

The construction of large dams and reservoirs on the river may disrupt the natural flow of water, impacting India’s northeastern states of Arunachal Pradesh and Assam. The reduction in water flow or the alteration of seasonal discharge could lead to reduced agricultural productivity in these regions, particularly in Assam, which depends heavily on the silt-rich waters of the Brahmaputra for rice cultivation. Furthermore, the interruption of natural silt flow could affect local biodiversity and ecosystems, leading to potential ecological degradation.

Moreover, the region is known for its seismic activity and vulnerability to natural disasters, including landslides and earthquakes. A dam collapse or significant disruption in water flow, similar to the 2005 Parechu Lake incident, could trigger catastrophic floods downstream. This would threaten the lives and livelihoods of millions of people across India, especially in flood-prone areas of Assam and Bengal.

Geopolitical Ramifications for India

Geopolitically, China’s development of the Medog Hydropower Station poses significant challenges for India, particularly regarding transboundary water cooperation. India is a lower riparian state, and any changes in water management practices by China could severely affect India’s water security. China’s lack of transparency in sharing data on water flow and dam operations exacerbates the potential for disputes. India’s concerns about the project mirror its apprehension regarding China’s previous activities on shared rivers, such as the Mekong River, where Chinese dams have significantly reduced water flow to downstream countries.

The expiration of the Brahmaputra Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between India and China in 2023 highlights the limited scope of existing agreements and the lack of meaningful cooperation on transboundary river management. While China has assured India that its dams are "run-of-the-river" projects, which are designed to minimize water storage and impoundment, the sheer scale of the Medog project calls into question the accuracy of such claims. India has repeatedly emphasized the need for greater transparency, data sharing, and mutual cooperation to avoid potential conflicts over shared water resources.

The situation is further complicated by India’s strategic interests in Arunachal Pradesh, which China claims as part of its territory. The development of infrastructure projects like the Medog Hydropower Station could be seen by India as part of China's broader geopolitical agenda in the region, adding another layer of complexity to an already tense border dispute.

Environmental Implications and Risks

The environmental ramifications of the Medog Hydropower Station are profound. The Yarlung Tsangpo flows through some of the world’s most ecologically fragile and sensitive regions, including high-altitude mountains and areas prone to seismic activity. Large-scale hydroelectric projects have the potential to alter river ecosystems, disrupt wildlife habitats, and contribute to soil erosion and landslides.

Furthermore, as seen in the case of the Three Gorges Dam, large dams can lead to changes in the gravitational pull on Earth, resulting in anomalies that could affect the seismic stability of the region. These changes can trigger earthquakes or landslides, endangering the surrounding environment and communities. The accumulation of such a large volume of water behind the Medog dam could lead to shifts in the region’s tectonic plates, causing unanticipated natural disasters.

Additionally, the relocation of communities living along the river could be a significant issue. Like other large-scale infrastructure projects, the Medog Hydropower Station could displace millions of people, leading to socioeconomic and cultural disruptions. China’s track record in resettling displaced populations from similar projects has raised concerns about the human cost of such undertakings.

The dam (or dams) could impact the flow of water from China to India, the lower riparian state.

Conclusion

The development of the Medog Hydropower Station on the Yarlung Tsangpo River is a major development that could have serious geopolitical and environmental ramifications, especially for India. While China has justified the project as a step toward achieving carbon neutrality by 2060, India’s concerns regarding water flow, environmental degradation, and geopolitical implications are legitimate. The need for transparent dialogue and cooperation on shared water resources has never been more critical. As China pushes forward with this ambitious project, it is essential that both countries engage in meaningful discussions to address potential risks, ensure the protection of ecosystems, and avoid exacerbating tensions. The future of the Brahmaputra River, along with the millions of lives that depend on it, hinges on the ability of China and India to collaborate effectively on this pressing issue.

Useful Links

Quick Links