The Political Orchestration of Riots: Lessons from Nagpur

1. Violence erupted in Nagpur on March 17 following controversies surrounding Aurangzeb’s tomb.
2. The situation escalated due to rumors of Quran burning, which fueled public outrage and unrest.
3. Amid the chaos, reports emerged of a police officer being assaulted, adding to the law-and-order crisis.

 

Riots in India: Manufactured, Not Spontaneous
 

1. Empirical evidence suggests that riots in India are often strategically influenced rather than being spontaneous eruptions of social tensions.
2. The Nagpur violence, which left dozens injured, cannot be attributed solely to rumors or impulsive reactions.
    

 Political Rhetoric and the Use of Historical Narratives
 

1. Since the Maharashtra Budget session began on March 3, historical figures have been invoked as a political talking point.
2. The fact that a medieval ruler remains central to contemporary political discourse highlights:
   • Misplaced governance priorities.
   • Deliberate attempts to manufacture controversies to shift focus from economic concerns.
      

Maharashtra’s Real Issues Ignored
 

1. The State, particularly its rural regions, faces serious socio-economic challenges, including:
   1. Inflation.
   2. Agrarian distress and related hardships.
   3. Widespread economic instability.
2. Instead of focusing on practical solutions, public discourse appears diverted toward divisive narratives.
    

 Political Strategy: Mobilization for Electoral Gains
 

1. During the recent Assembly elections, historical figures and past events were consistently referenced to create political narratives.
2. The intent behind this approach:

1. Mobilize a broader electoral base through identity-based appeals.
2. Shape public perception by linking present events to historical figures.

3. Research indicates that societies with strong civic engagement and inter-community cooperation are less prone to unrest.
4. The occurrence of violence in Nagpur, a city with significant historical and political importance, raises concerns about the effectiveness of conflict prevention strategies.
    

 The Role of Cinema in Political Discourse
 

1. The recent success of a historical film depicting past conflicts has further fueled contemporary discourse.
2. Attributing unrest to the film’s popularity serves as a convenient deflection, shifting attention from broader socio-political factors influencing tensions.
    

The Need for a Shift in Governance Priorities
 

1. Maharashtra must reclaim its leadership in development-focused governance, prioritizing economic and social well-being over divisive rhetoric.
2. Public awareness and civil society initiatives should push back against the use of history as a tool for polarization.
3. Promoting inclusive discourse and addressing core governance issues is essential for ensuring long-term social stability and progress.
    

Communal Mobilization as a Political Strategy: A Critical Analysis
 

1. Understanding Mobilization through Identity Politics
 

1. Mobilization based on religious, ethnic, or sectarian identities is used to consolidate political support.
2. Tactics: Political actors exploit historical grievances, cultural symbols, and perceived insecurities to rally public sentiment.
3. Objective: The goal is to polarize communities, ensuring a consolidated electoral base, while diverting focus from core governance issues.
    

2. Historical Context of Identity-Based Mobilization in India

Partition-era Politics (Pre-1947)
 

1. The colonial policy of divide and rule deepened social divisions.
2. Political organizations used identity-based appeals to consolidate their respective support bases.

Post-Independence Identity Politics

1. While secularism was embedded in India’s Constitution, political competition increasingly became identity-driven.
2. Riots and polarization tactics have been used to influence elections, particularly since the 1980s.

Rise of Identity-Based Politics (1990s-Present)

1. Events such as historical site disputes and past communal conflicts have been leveraged for political gains.
2. Recent trends include:
   • Renaming of places and historical revisionism to reshape national narratives.
   • Selective references to past rulers and empires to create contrasting identities.
      

 Key Strategies of Political Mobilization Through Identity
 

1. Historical and Cultural Narratives

1. Reinterpretation of historical events to frame one group as dominant and another as adversarial.
2. Renaming places and reframing public memory to strengthen ideological affiliations.

2. Coded Messaging and Polarizing Discourse

1. Use of indirect language that evokes historical injustices or cultural pride, without explicitly promoting division.
2. Public speeches, media campaigns, and digital platforms play a crucial role in amplifying these narratives.

3. Electoral Engineering and Conflict-Oriented Politics

1. Strategic unrest before elections creates an environment of heightened identity-based consciousness.
2. Identity-based political appeals help in solidifying voter bases while fragmenting opposition coalitions.

4. Symbolism and Public Events

1. State-backed religious, cultural, or memorial events reinforce political identity.
2. Selective commemorations or erasures of historical events reshape public narratives.

5. Economic and Social Exclusion

1. Deprivation of certain social groups fosters a sense of victimhood, which political actors can exploit.
2. Framing economic challenges as identity-based issues redirects public discontent towards rival groups instead of governance failures.
    

 Impact of Identity-Based Mobilization
 

1. Electoral Gains and Vote Bank Politics

1. Divided societies vote along identity lines, reducing the impact of issue-based campaigns.
2. Weakened opposition unity due to fragmentation along identity groups.

2. Erosion of Democratic and Constitutional Principles

1. Undermines secularism and pluralism, essential for democratic functioning.
2. State institutions, law enforcement, and media become politicized to support dominant narratives.

3. Economic and Social Disruptions

1. Heightened tensions affect economic stability, particularly in regions with frequent unrest.
2. Investors and businesses withdraw from conflict-prone areas, leading to long-term economic consequences.

4. Rise in Hate Crimes and Social Marginalization

1. Increased communal tensions lead to discrimination in education, employment, and public services.
2. Inter-community relationships and social coexistence weaken, increasing long-term divisions.
    

Countering the Politics of Identity-Based Mobilization
 

1. Strengthening Social Integration and Civic Engagement

1. Encouraging inter-community collaboration and dialogue to counter divisive narratives.
2. Grassroots peace initiatives to build trust and cooperation across identities.

2. Media Accountability and Ethical Journalism

1. Reducing sensationalism in news reporting to prevent exaggeration of identity-based conflicts.
2. Social media regulation to curb hate speech and misinformation.

3. Political and Electoral Reforms

1. Stronger laws against hate speech and divisive campaigns.
2. Electoral reforms to discourage identity-based mobilization strategies.

4. Public Awareness on Developmental Priorities

1. Shifting political discourse from identity-based narratives to economic development, education, healthcare, and employment.
2. Encouraging voter awareness campaigns to emphasize policy-based decision-making rather than emotional or divisive appeals.
3. Strengthening civic education in schools and colleges to promote rational discourse and critical thinking about political strategies.
4. Engaging youth and grassroots organizations to counter identity-based mobilization with fact-based discussions on governance and development.

5. Strengthening Institutional Safeguards

1. Empowering the Election Commission with greater authority to regulate divisive political campaigns and enforce a level playing field.
2. Ensuring judicial independence so that legal institutions can act against communal propaganda without political interference.
3. Strengthening parliamentary oversight to hold leaders accountable for identity-based rhetoric in electoral campaigns.
4. Monitoring state institutions and law enforcement to prevent selective action that fuels divisions.

6. Promoting Inclusive Economic Growth

1. Addressing regional economic disparities to prevent grievance-based identity politics from taking root.
2. Creating job opportunities and skill development programs in underserved areas to reduce migration-based or community-based economic insecurities.
3. Encouraging corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives that foster social integration through community development projects.
4. Boosting investments in education and healthcare to reduce reliance on identity-based mobilization as a political tool.

7. Building a Culture of Dialogue and Reconciliation

1. Encouraging inter-community dialogues to break down stereotypes and foster mutual understanding.
2. Promoting conflict resolution mechanisms at local levels to address grievances before they escalate into larger disputes.
3. Using social media and digital platforms to spread positive narratives that counter divisive propaganda.
4. Encouraging moderate voices and peacebuilding initiatives through cultural and academic institutions.

8. Moving Towards a Constructive Political Culture

1. Communal mobilization is a short-term political strategy with long-term consequences for democracy, economy, and social harmony.
2. Reforming political institutions, strengthening governance, and investing in public awareness are key to countering identity-based electoral strategies.
3. A focus on inclusive development and rational discourse will ensure that elections are fought on policies and governance, rather than identity divisions.
4. Political accountability, voter awareness, and institutional resilience are crucial to preserving democracy and social stability in the long run.

 

Also Read
NCERT Books For UPSC	UPSC Daily Current Affairs
UPSC Monthly Magazine	Best IAS Coaching in Delhi
Free MCQs for UPSC Prelims	UPSC Test Series
ENSURE IAS NOTES	Our Booklist