Context:
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) recently released the annual report titled ‘State Finances: A Study of Budget of 2023-24’ with a focus on 'Revenue Dynamics and Fiscal Capacity of Indian States'.
Key Findings of the Report
- Prudent (well-judged/wise) Fiscal Management: States' consolidated gross fiscal deficit to gross domestic product (GFD-GDP) ratio decreased by 1.3% (4.1% in 2020-21 to 2.8% in 2021-22).
- This decline resulted from a moderation (within reasonable limits) in revenue expenditure and an increase in revenue collection.
- Gross fiscal deficit (GFD) is the amount by which a government's total expenditure exceeds its revenue receipts and non-debt capital receipts (receipts that the government receives from the sale of old assets).
- Increased Capital Outlay: Capital outlay (capital expenditure) is projected to rise by 42.6% in 2023-24, reaching 2.9% of GDP. Capital outlay involves spending on asset creation, influencing economic output positively.
- States’ Total Outstanding Liabilities: The debt-to-GDP ratio of states decreased from 31% (March 2021) to 27.5% (March 2023).
- Despite this, outstanding liabilities may remain above 30% of Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) for many states.
- The debt-to-GDP ratio measures the proportion of a country's national debt to its gross domestic product.
- Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) is the sum total volume of all finished goods and services produced during a given period of time, usually a year, within the geographical boundaries of the State.
- Support from the Centre, in the form of 50-year interest-free capex loans, aided in reducing states’ interest burden.
- Net Market Borrowings: States' reliance on net market borrowings decreased to 76% in the budgeted gross fiscal deficit (GFD) for 2023-24. This decline is attributed to an increase in states' loans from the Centre.
- Increased Tax Buoyancy: Implementation of goods and services tax (GST) resulted in enhanced tax buoyancy for the states. GST implementation contributed to greater formalization of the economy, expanding the tax base.
- Tax buoyancy is a key indicator used to measure the efficiency of a government's tax system. It is a measure of how responsive a country's tax revenue is to changes in its Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
- Committed Expenditure: It includes interest payments, administrative services, and pension. It is expected to remain at 4.5% of GDP.
Concerns Regarding State Finances
|
Solutions
|
- Non-tax revenues remain at around 1% of GDP, significantly lower than some countries.
|
- Revise user charges, royalties, and premiums, and explore asset monetization.
|
- Allocations for key sectors have been reduced, impacting development initiatives.
|
- Link conditional transfers to reforms, encouraging states to improve economic performance.
|
- Reverting to Old Pension Scheme would strain state finances, limiting growth-oriented expenditures.
|
- Enhance fiscal capacity for efficient service delivery and capital investment.
|
- Further provision of non-merit goods and services could jeopardize (put something at risk) fiscal consolidation.
|
- Streamline fund transfers, enhance banking arrangements, and improve cash management practices.
|
- Illegal mining poses a threat to revenue.
|
- Use Geographic Information Systems and Drone Surveys to identify and curb illegal mining activities.
|
- Inadequate progress toward climate goals.
|
- Introduce incentives for states making significant strides in achieving national climate goals.
|
Important Concepts
- N K Singh Committee Recommendations:
- The combined debt-to-GDP ratio of the center and states should be reduced to 60% by 2023 (comprising 40% for the Centre and 20% for states).
- The committee suggests incorporating (including) "escape clauses" allowing deviation from fiscal targets under specific circumstances like national security, acts of war, national calamities, etc.
- Important Non-tax Revenue Sources:
- Lease/sale of natural resources, such as minerals.
- User charges on economic/social services provided by the government, like irrigation, electricity, health, education, forestry, and wildlife.
- Lotteries.
- Interest receipts from loans extended to entities like public sector undertakings (PSUs) and local bodies.
- Fiscal Capacity of States:
- Fiscal Capacity reflects the State govt’s ability to meet expenditures through its own revenue receipts. Currently, the States finance only 58% of their revenue expenditure from their own revenue sources.
- Factors contributing to Fiscal Capacity include lower share of agriculture GSDP, high per capita income, high education levels, low inflation, low corruption, and lower size of the shadow economy.
|