GOVERNMENT POLICIES AND INTERVENTIONS FOR DEVELOPMENT IN VARIOUS SECTORS AND ISSUES ARISING OUT OF THEIR DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION

GOVERNMENT POLICY MAKING

Definition: Public policy is an institutionalized proposal or a decided set of elements like laws, regulations, guidelines, and actions to solve or address relevant and real-world problems, guided by a conception and often implemented by programs. Public policy can be considered to be the sum of a government's direct and indirect activities and has been conceptualized in a variety of ways.

Making policies is an ongoing process. Once a policy is approved or adopted, it does not end. As Anderson points out: "Policy is being made as it is being administered and administered as it is being made."

Stages in the Policy Formulation

In his analysis of the policy process, Thomas Dye (2004) outlines the following stages:

1. Identifying the issue: the identification of policy issues through demands for action on the part of the government.
2. Making plans: focusing the media and public officials' attention on specific public issues before making a decision.
3. Making a policy: the creation of policy proposals by interest groups, chief executive officers, legislative committees, think tanks, and other groups.
4. Legitimation of Policy: the selection of policies and their implementation through political actions taken by the executive, legislature, and courts.
5. Application of the Policy: the activities of executive agencies, public expenditures, and the organization of bureaucracies that carry out policies.
6. Evaluation of Policies: the public, press, outside consultants, and government agencies themselves evaluating policies.

FORMULATION OF PUBLIC POLICY

Constitutional Framework for Policy-Making:

In India, policymaking is shaped by the constitutional system, with four characteristics that stand out the most: democratic and sovereign republic, parliamentary system, constitutional federalism, and a broad socioeconomic philosophy are all present in the preamble, chapters on fundamental rights, and the state policy directive principles.

Policy-making is an essential function at all levels of government. Under Article 77(3) of the Constitution, certain guidelines have been established for the management of government business. The procedure for making decisions is governed by the Rules of Business, and the Council of Ministers, particularly the cabinet, makes policy decisions within the scope of these rules.

Institutional Factors India's policymaking is influenced by more than just these four constitutional factors.

1. Legislature: In India, the highest body for making public policy is the parliament. It is in charge because the council of ministers, which is led by the Prime Minister, needs the support of a majority in parliament to continue. It makes laws that make the policies become law. Additionally, it gives the government's policy decisions legitimacy.
2. Executive: The executive is required by law to select the policies that will be presented to Parliament. The President of India, the Council of Ministers, and the government machinery make up the executive at the Union level in India.
3. Judiciary: In addition, the Indian judiciary has a positive impact on the development and implementation of public policies in two ways: a) through its judicial review authority and b) through judicial decisions.
4. Institutions outside of the government: In addition, informal participants in the policy process include political parties, pressure groups, the media, and citizens. The process of making policies greatly benefits from their perspectives and influence.

Problems with India's Public Policy Making

1. Fragmentation in the Policy Making Process: One of the main issues with India's Public Policy Making is the extreme structure fragmentation. This kind of fragmentation doesn't take into account the fact that decisions made in one sector can have serious repercussions in other sectors and may conflict with policies in other sectors. In addition, it becomes extremely challenging for even closely related industries to align their policies with a common overarching agenda.
2. Too much overlap between policymaking and policy application: Secretaries devote a significant portion of their time to the day-to-day administration of existing policies. Meetings and functions on implementation issues, as well as anticipating and responding to questions from the parliamentary committee, consume time. As a result, poor policies that fail to take into account the needs of citizens are more likely to emerge.
3. Aversion of input from outside the government: Public policy is made without adequate discussion of the issues at hand and without adequate input from outside the government. In many areas, the best expertise is outside of the government. However, there is no systematic method for obtaining outside input, involving those impacted by policies, or debating alternatives and their effects on various groups in the Government's policy processes and structures. Before a policy is implemented, it is subject to extensive public debate in the majority of developed nations.
4. Poor pre-policy discussions: Without adequate cost-benefit analysis, trade-off analysis, and consequences, policy decisions are frequently made. This is due to a number of underlying factors, including inadequate consultation with in-house specialists, inadequate professionalism among policymakers and advisors, and so on.

Reforming the Process of Making and Putting Policies into Action:

1. Reduced fragmentation; separation of policy-making and policy-implementation; decentralization of authority for policy-implementation; expansion and enhancement of the knowledge base utilized in policy-making; and encouragement of integration and synthesis.
2. Formulation of policies based on evidence.
3. Establishing an independent "Monitoring Trust" as an integral part of all important public policies and programs and improving the competence and skills of policymakers Stakeholders and social activists, in addition to core technical, administrative, and legal members, may be included in the proposed Trust.
4. Policy formulation and implementation are democratized and enhanced by sharing information and progress through dashboards and other technology tools and inviting suggestions through IT portals like MyGov.

Must Check: IAS Coaching Institute In Delhi