Context
- The Tamil Nadu Minister has been convicted in a disproportionate asset case by the Madras High Court.
- The conviction, 12 years after the FIR registration in 2011, may lead to his disqualification as a Member of the Legislative Assembly (MLA) unless overturned.

Provisions for Disqualification of an MLA
Constitutional
|
- Article 191- disqualifications for State Legislative Assembly (SLA) or Legislative Council membership.
- Disqualification grounds include holding a government office of profit, being declared mentally unsound, undischarged insolvency, non-Indian citizenship, or allegiance to a foreign state.
- Parliament-made laws or disqualification on defection grounds under the 10th Schedule are also covered. This involves changing party affiliation before or after an election.
|
Representation of the People Act (RPA), 1951
|
Disqualification Criteria:
- Legislators convicted under the Prevention of Corruption Act (PCA), 1988, face a six-year disqualification if the penalty is a fine.
- Imprisonment under the PCA results in disqualification from conviction until release and an additional six years.
- Preventive detention doesn't cause disqualification.
- Conviction stay or set aside is necessary to avoid disqualification.
Additional Disqualification Conditions:
- No guilt in specific election offenses or corrupt practices.
- No dismissal from government service due to corruption or disloyalty.
- No conviction for promoting enmity, bribery, or failure to report election expenses on time.
- No interest in government contracts, works, or services.
- Not a director or managing agent in a government-held corporation.
- No punishment for social crimes like untouchability, dowry, or sati.
- Governor's Decision and Reversal:
- Governor's decision on disqualification is final, with prior Election Commission consultation.
- Disqualification can be overturned if a higher court grants a stay or decides an appeal in favour of the convicted lawmaker.
|
How Disqualification Differs from Suspension?
- Suspension Definition: Temporary loss of membership due to misconduct or rule violation.
Rules 373, 374, and 374A in Lok Sabha, and Rules 255 and 256 in Rajya Sabha regulate suspension.
- Suspension Conditions: Withdrawal for “grossly disorderly” conduct or wilful obstruction. Maximum suspension is “for five consecutive sittings or the remainder of the session, whichever is less.”
- State Assembly Rules: Each state has its own assembly conduct rules, specifying the maximum suspension not exceeding the session's remainder.